A Thousand Perfect Notes Review

A Book Spun From “Sugar and Charcoal” // Author: C.G. Drews // Rating: 5/5

36389267Synopsis: An emotionally charged story of music, abuse and, ultimately, hope.

Beck hates his life. He hates his violent mother. He hates his home. Most of all, he hates the piano that his mother forces him to play hour after hour, day after day. He will never play as she did before illness ended her career and left her bitter and broken. But Beck is too scared to stand up to his mother, and tell her his true passion, which is composing his own music – because the least suggestion of rebellion on his part ends in violence.

When Beck meets August, a girl full of life, energy and laughter, love begins to awaken within him and he glimpses a way to escape his painful existence. But dare he reach for it?


“What he wants most in the world is to cut off his own hands.”

This is how this book starts. And it doesn’t forget this beginning. And it is all the more beautiful for it.

TW/CW: violence (from a parent, self harm fantasies, neglect)

Beck and his love for music

C.G. Drews has accomplished something memorable and heart-string-snapping in her debut: I care about her main character, so so much. Beck loves music, I truly believe he does, but his mother has confined, constrained, and punished him into only listening and playing classical music. So his view of music is so warped and tragic. He is a born composer but doesn’t trust his own hands and heart. He is a child with no one to turn to with too much of his corner of the world on his shoulders. C.G. Drews captures that desolate feeling so well, and this is a tough book to read, but brilliantly done.

His relationship, his awakening with August, is something beautiful to behold. I don’t know; I didn’t see her as a manic pixie dream girl, come to “save” Beck from his situation. She was just lucky in her circumstances, and truly sweet, to reach out to a forgotten friend. We see August through Beck’s scope only: “August’s eyes say she’s never been let down in her entire life. Lucky her.” How is someone so abused as Beck supposed to register or compute someone as light and carefree and shoeless and soul-beautiful as August? This book may be a fast read, but it sticks with you. These characters stick with you, and you just want the best for them.

Beck and his little sister, his true hope spot

Joey honestly killed me and Beck’s spineless/hopeless/pillar-strong love for her. What can a teenager do in a situation like this? I loved their relationship. This, Joey, is the true catalyst for Beck fightingfightingfighting for his freedom from the Maestro. I’ve been in a K-8 school for a year (my freshest remembrance of how children speak) and Joey rang true for me, and especially Beck’s view of her: something to protect, and keep playful around and encourage, especially when encouraging a kid sister to shut out your love interest is A+++ goals.

Beck and August, a burnt marshmallow and his shining north star

“But he hopes her smile returns when he’s gone, because it’s a cruel person who steals smiles.”

When August crashes into Beck’s life, it’s a matter of a school assignment, of chance. She seems too good to be true… but the writing buoyed me along. There was cake and contrasting families and heartbreak and tough choices and August was both a huge part of Beck’s clawing his way to the surface of something good and also just an idea. I would definitely read a sequel with these characters, or grasp at authorial shout-outs in other works. Suffice it to say, I ship Beck and August hard because they ground and uplift each other in equal measure.

“He hates it because she is hope and tomorrow and he’s a goodbye and the end.”

Beck and the Maestro (and his aggro uncle Jan)

The Maestro is a monster, and is mostly seen through Beck’s eyes… I think this worked well for the story, because (although I didn’t have the physical abuse aspect growing up) I think quite a few of us readers could sympathize with having a parent that is so demanding, so confusingly angry, that you’re stuck. Frozen. Unable to make a choice until it’s almost too late.

“He plays for hours. He forgets cake and freedom and August. It’s better this way.”

“He wishes, just once, he could play them perfectly for her [the Maestro] since she’s had every note she loved snatched away.”

Beck still  loves the Maestro. (How could he not? She’s his mother… no matter what, that connection doesn’t just go away. It really doesn’t. And it is awful… but hopefully you meet many more people besides, who help you, but still.) And I think that’s a great nuance this book achieves, both loving and hating your parents because what can you do.

One of the things that really confused/upset me about this book, however // highlight for spoilers: his uncle Jan. What the actual f///. Jan basically mindf///s Beck, acts all scary and slamming sh*t, because he wants to know how the young man truly feels about music?? “I apologize for the theatrics, though, my nephew. I needed to know you honestly.” WHY would you scare an abused child like that?? I just… that baffled me and I hope Beck is okay and again would definitely read a thousand more words of Beck and August Skyping and sending each other snailmail love letters and inspiring each other to be better versions of themselves despite the distance… but I don’t think I’ll ever trust Jan!!

Overall, this book THIS BOOK

“Sharing music is personal because music speaks, it feels, it breathes. And it always says something about you.”

It’s about music and breathing it in and screaming it out until it saves you. It’s about those lucky chances to get to connect with someone who might help you through the darkest times. What Beck wants most in the world is to cut off his own hands; what Beck wants most in the world is to live his life on his own terms. And he fights for that, with a little help from his friend, from his sister, from his estranged uncle, but ultimately, Beck pulls everything out of himself to find it within himself to live. And I admire that. And I admire this author for the story she brought to the world.


Have you read A Thousand Perfect Notes? What did you think? Did you know you can make a version of the cake from ATPN? I think that’s wicked awesome.


10 thoughts on “A Thousand Perfect Notes Review

  1. First, what an amazing review (as usual). I really feel like I’m there with the characters. It’s such a sad thing when a parent imposes their dreams through their child so they can live their own dreams vicariously. Beck shouldn’t be an extension of herself, he is a whole and complete person that is separate to his mother.
    I love how you haven’t trivialise August to a manic pixie dream girl, again, they are complete persons too and instead of calling them that, we should call them a good friend instead as you rightly pointed out.
    Also, the relationship between Beck and his little sister is giving me major Holden and Phoebe vibes.
    It makes me really happy to see that Beck found it within himself to pluck up his courage. It’s okay to have someone help you and lift you up as well as do it for your own self.
    Now, I need to add this book to my TBR!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Oh I’ve never read Catcher in the Rye so had no idea that he had a little sister. I’ve always meant to pick it up, esp because so many people are split about it.

      Hope you like ATPN when you read it! It was really lovely and I’m very much looking forward to her next book. ❤

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Ooo, it’d be interesting to see how you feel about it. The people who dislike Holden can not deny that, for the most part, his insights are spot on. I really can’t call whether you’d like it, honestly…

        I can’t wait to read it too, I hope it’s just as good or better than ATPN. ❤️

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s